I saw some of you play this on twitter and thought we could maybe have our own forum version of this with slightly more substantial responses.

Rules are simple: Ask the poster above you to choose between two games of roughly similar perceived value/importance. Once they have answered, it becomes the turn of the one who asked the question to be challenged by whoever wants to. Rinse and repeat.

Join in, it'll be fun!


Edit: Might as well just quote the person you want to ask to avoid confusion.

Alright, poster above, which should I spend my hard-earned cash on, Resident Evil 7 or Alien Isolation?

Mass Effect 2

Resident Evil 2

Close this thread, Chopper ruining everything again!

(Probably Alien Isolation)

Next!

Edit: In case the second one was for me as well, Resident Evil 2. Without a shadow of a doubt.

Someone who has played both do Dom's then

Play both......but probably Resi 2.

Shovel Knight or Mega man Collection for Switch? - I haven't played many platform games over the past few years, but I recently finished -the amazing-Hollow Knight and looking for something to fill that hole in my life.

^^^^ I would say the Mega Man Collection (especially Mega Man 2, 3 and maybe 7 and 8), but if you're not a die hard old school platform fan, Shovel Knight might cater more to your sensibilities.

I'll go; I'm not trying to make this all about RE but looking at my unplayed games:

Resident Evil 5 or Resident Evil 6?

...Would it be rude of me to point out that the original idea behind this thread was to ask others to choose between two games of similar quality instead of looking for personal recommendations?

Anyway, since it doesn't seem to be gaining much traction, I'd say RE5 is probably a better game than RE6. They're both near the bottom of the mainline RE pile for my money, and RE5's main downside is that it was designed as a coop game first and foremost, but even in singleplayer it is a much tighter, more polished and better designed game than RE6. RE6's combat system does have its fans, though. (And as much as I dislike the game otherwise, I am one of them).

RE5 duo > RE5 solo > RE6

well, I was just wondering which was better, they seem to be of similar quality and I just happen to own them.

The distinction is mostly lost on me however!

Portal or Portal 2?

Chopper wrote: ↑July 31st, 2018, 12:03 pm Portal or Portal 2?

Portal.

Was a more refined and a better, focused experience I thought.


Warioland 2 or Warioland 3 ?