I have played a lot of horror games, but no game has scared the pants off me quite like Subnautica. I bought this game in Early Access thinking it looked like a relaxing submarine base-building game in a coral reef. And for the first couple hours it is. I built my first base, I built some gear, I bu...

It is quite certainly already on the list since you have done a podcast on the first game in the series, but I'd like to suggest Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door.